
.. _basictutaliasing:

=======================================================
Understanding Memory Aliasing for Speed and Correctness
=======================================================

The aggressive reuse of memory is one of the ways Theano makes code fast, and
it's important for the correctness and speed of your program that you understand
which buffers Theano might alias to which others.

This file describes the principles for how Theano treats memory, and explains
when you might want to change the default behaviour of some functions and
methods for faster performance.


The memory model: 2 spaces
==========================

There are some simple principles that guide Theano's treatment of memory.  The
main idea is that there is a pool of memory managed by Theano, and Theano tracks
changes to values in that pool.

 1. Theano manages its own memory space, which typically does not overlap with
    the memory of normal python variables that non-Theano code creates.

 1. Theano Functions only modify buffers that are in Theano's memory space.

 1. Theano's memory space includes the buffers allocated to store shared
    variables and the temporaries used to evaluate Functions.

 1. Physically, Theano's memory space may be spread across the host, a GPU
    device(s), and in the future may even include objects on a remote machine.

 1. The memory allocated for a shared variable buffer is unique: it is never
    aliased to another shared variable.

 1. Theano's managed memory is constant while Theano Functions are not running
    and Theano library code is not running.

 1. The default behaviour of Function is to return user-space values for
    outputs, and to expect user-space values for inputs.
    
The distinction between Theano-managed memory and user-managed memory can be
broken down by some Theano functions (e.g. shared, get_value and the
constructors for In and Out) by using
a ``borrow=True`` flag.  This can make those methods faster (by avoiding copy
operations) at the expense of risking subtle bugs in the overall program (by
aliasing memory).

The rest of this section is aimed at helping you to understand when it is safe
to use the ``borrow=True`` argument and reap the benefit of faster code.

Borrowing when creating shared variables
========================================

A ``borrow`` argument can be provided to the shared-variable constructor.


.. If you modify this code, also change :
.. theano/tests/test_tutorial.py:T_aliasing.test_aliasing_1

.. code-block:: python

    import numpy, theano
    np_array = numpy.ones(2, dtype='float32')

    s_default = theano.shared(np_array)
    s_false   = theano.shared(np_array, borrow=False)
    s_true    = theano.shared(np_array, borrow=True)

By default (``s_default``) and when explicitly setting ``borrow=False``, the
shared variable we construct gets a [deep] copy of ``np_array``.  So changes we
subsequently make to ``np_array`` have no effect on our shared variable.

.. code-block:: python

    np_array += 1 # now it is an array of 2.0 s

    s_default.value  # -> array([1.0, 1.0])
    s_false.value    # -> array([1.0, 1.0])
    s_true.value    # -> array([2.0, 2.0])

If we are running this with the CPU as the device, 
then changes we make to np_array *right away* will show up in ``s_true.value``
because numpy arrays are mutable, and ``s_true`` is using the ``np_array``
object as it's internal buffer.

However, this aliasing of ``np_array`` and ``s_true`` is not guaranteed to occur,
and may occur only temporarily even if it occurs at all.
It is not guaranteed to occur because if Theano is using a GPU device, then the
borrow flag has no effect.
It may occur only temporarily because
if we call a Theano function that updates the value of ``s_true`` the aliasing
relationship *may* or *may not* be broken (the function is allowed to 
update the shared variable by modifying its buffer, which will preserve
the aliasing, or by changing which buffer the variable points to, which
will terminate the aliasing).

*Take home message:*

It is safe practice (and a good idea) to use ``borrow=True`` in a shared
variable constructor when the shared variable stands for a large object (in
terms of memory footprint) and you do not want to create copies of it in memory
.

It is not a reliable technique to use ``borrow=True`` to modify shared variables
by side-effect, because with some devices (e.g. GPU devices) this technique will
not work.

Borrowing when accessing value of shared variables
==================================================

Retrieving
----------

A ``borrow`` argument can also be used to control how a shared variable's value is retrieved.


.. If you modify this code, also change :
.. theano/tests/test_tutorial.py:T_aliasing.test_aliasing_2

.. code-block:: python

    s = theano.shared(np_array)

    v_false = s.get_value(borrow=False) # N.B. borrow default is False
    v_true = s.get_value(borrow=True)


When ``borrow=False`` is passed to ``get_value``, it means that the return value
may not be aliased to any part of Theano's internal memory.
When ``borrow=True`` is passed to ``get_value``, it means that the return value
*might* be aliased to some of Theano's internal memory.
But both of these calls might create copies of the internal memory.

The reason that ``borrow=True`` might still make a copy is that the internal
representation of a shared variable might not be what you expect.  When you
create a shared variable by passing a numpy array for example, then ``get_value()``
must return a numpy array too.  That's how Theano can make the GPU use
transparent.  But when you are using a GPU (or in future perhaps a remote machine), then the numpy.ndarray
is not the internal representation of your data.
If you really want Theano to return its internal representation *and never copy it*
then you should use the ``return_internal_type=True`` argument to
``get_value``.  It will never copy the internal object (always return in
constant time), but might return various datatypes depending on contextual
factors (e.g. the compute device, the dtype of the numpy array).

.. code-block:: python

    v_internal = s.get_value(borrow=True, return_internal_type=True)

It is possible to use ``borrow=False`` in conjunction with
``return_internal_type=True``, which will return a deep copy of the internal object.
This is primarily for internal debugging, not for typical use.

*Take home message:*

It is safe (and sometimes much faster) to use ``get_value(borrow=True)`` when
your code does not modify the return value.  *Do not use this to modify a shared
variable by side-effect* because it will make your code device-dependent.
Modification of GPU variables by this sort of side-effect is impossible.

Assigning
---------

Shared variables also have a ``set_value`` method that can accept an optional ``borrow=True`` argument.
The semantics are similar to those of creating a new shared variable -
``borrow=False`` is the default and ``borrow=True`` means that Theano *may*
reuse the buffer you provide as the internal storage for the variable.

A standard pattern for manually updating the value of a shared variable is as
follows.

.. code-block:: python

    s.set_value(
        some_inplace_fn(s.get_value(borrow=True)),
        borrow=True)

This pattern works regardless of the compute device, and when the compute device
makes it possible to expose Theano's internal variables without a copy, then it
goes as fast as an in-place update.

Retrieving and assigning via the .value property
------------------------------------------------

Shared variables have a ``.value`` property that is connected to ``get_value``
and ``set_value``.  The borrowing behaviour of the property is controlled by a
boolean configuration variable ``config.shared.value_borrows``, which currently
defaults to ``True``.  If that variable is ``True`` then an assignment like ``s.value=v``
is equivalent to ``s.set_value(v, borrow=True)``, and a retrieval like ``print
s.value`` is equivalent to ``print s.get_value(borrow=True)``.  Likewise, 
if ``config.shared.value_borrows`` is ``False``, then the borrow parameter that the ``.value`` property 
passes to ``set_value`` and ``get_value`` is ``False``.

The ``True`` default value of ``config.shared.value_borrows`` means that
aliasing can sometimes happen and sometimes not, which can be confusing. 
Be aware that the default value may be changed to ``False`` sometime in the
not-to-distant future. This change will create more copies, and potentially slow
down code that accesses ``.value`` attributes inside tight loops.  To avoid this
potential impact on your code, use the ``.get_value`` and ``.set_value`` methods
directly with appropriate flags.


Borrowing when constructing Function objects
============================================

A ``borrow`` argument can also be provided to the ``In`` and ``Out`` objects
that control how ``theano.function`` handles its arguments and return value[s]. 

.. If you modify this code, also change :
.. theano/tests/test_tutorial.py:T_aliasing.test_aliasing_3

.. code-block:: python

    import theano, theano.tensor

    x = theano.tensor.matrix()
    y = 2*x
    f = theano.function([theano.In(x, borrow=True)], theano.Out(y, borrow=True))

Borrowing an input means that Theano will treat the argument you provide as if
it were part of Theano's pool of temporaries.  Consequently, your input
may be reused as a buffer (and overwritten!) during the computation of other variables in the
course of evaluating that function (e.g. ``f``). 


Borrowing an output means that Theano will not insist on allocating a fresh
output buffer every time you call the function.  It will possibly reuse the same one as
a previous call, and overwrite the old contents.  Consequently, it may overwrite
old return values by side effect.
Those return values may also be overwritten in
the course of evaluating *another compiled function* (for example, the output
may be aliased to a shared variable).  So be careful to use a borrowed return
value right away before calling any more Theano functions.
The default is of course to *not borrow* internal results.

It is also possible to pass an ``return_internal_type=True`` flag to the ``Out``
variable which has the same interpretation as the ``return_internal_type`` flag
to the shared variable's ``get_value`` function.  Unlike ``get_value()``, the
combination of ``return_internal_type=True`` and ``borrow=True`` arguments to
``Out()`` are not guaranteed to avoid copying an output value.  They are just
hints that give more flexibility to the compilation and optimization of the
graph.

*Take home message:*
When an input ``x`` to a function is not needed after the function returns and you
would like to make it available to Theano as additional workspace, then consider
marking it with ``In(x, borrow=True)``.  It may make the function faster and
reduce its memory requirement.
When a return value ``y`` is large (in terms of memory footprint), and you only need to read from it once, right
away when it's returned, then consider marking it with an ``Out(y,
borrow=True)``.

